This page is the Simplified Technical English version of ZIP 1013. The source ZIP is the normative text. Read the writing rules to understand the marked words.
ZIP 1013: Keep It Simple, Zcashers: 10% to ECC, 10% to ZF
ZIP: 1013 Title: Keep It Simple, Zcashers: 10% to ECC, 10% to ZF Owners: Gordon Mohr (@gojomo on relevant forums) Status: Obsolete Category: Consensus Process Created: 2019-11-14 License: Public Domain Discussions-To: <https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/zip-keep-it-simple-zcashers-kisz-10-to-ecc-10-to-zfnd/35425> Pull-Request: <https://github.com/zcash/zips/pull/293>
Terminology
On this page, STE words are in the place of the BCP 14 key words of the source. Refer to the key word table.
These are the definitions of the terms in this ZIP:
- ECC
- The Electric Coin Company, a limited-liability corporation in the US.
- ZF
- The Zcash Foundation, a non-profit corporation in the US.
- Halvening
- A regularly scheduled discontinuity. At a Halvening, the rate of ZEC issuance decreases by half. The expected date of the first Halvening is approximately October 2020. The expected date of the next Halvening is approximately October 2024.
Abstract
This ZIP contains a proposal for these actions.
The "Founders’ Reward" is the protocol-based development funding for the bootstrap of the system. It expires at the 1st Zcash Halvening. After that Halvening, continue to send 20% of new ZEC issuance to activities that are related to development. These activities are for continued work on Zcash in these areas:
- Research.
- Development.
- Innovation.
- Maintenance.
Give half of these funds to the ECC, and half to the ZF. Continue this allocation until the 2nd Halvening.
Motivation
There are many proposals for possible allocations of Zcash block rewards (ZEC inflation) after the 1st Halvening. Many of these proposals have similar broad parameters:
- 20% of block rewards for continued development work.
- Payment of these block rewards to some combination of the Electric Coin Company (ECC), the Zcash Foundation (ZF), and other entities. Each of these other entities has a specified name, or is to be decided.
- Conditions on some new allocation formulas or management practices. These conditions often include new items of these types:
- Entities.
- Personnel.
- Processes for feedback and deliberation.
But no existing ZIP contains an explicit proposal for the simplest variation on this theme. That variation has the maximum continuity with previous practice. The purpose of this "Keep It Simple, Zcashers" ZIP is to fill that gap.
Requirements
The intention of this ZIP is that it is easy:
- To describe.
- To understand.
- To implement.
Non-requirements
This ZIP does not contain a proposal for a specific course of action after the 2nd Halvening.
Specification
To implement this ZIP, the Zcash protocol and compatible implementations must do these things:
- Keep an allotment of 20% of new ZEC issuance for development activities until the 2nd Halvening event. The expected date of this event is approximately October 2024.
- Formalize a 50-50 relative allocation between the ECC and ZF.
- Deliver these ZEC to addresses that the recipients supply. Use one of these methods:
- A method similar to the original "Founders’ Reward" block rewards in the consensus rules.
- Any other method that is preferred technically, legally or both, and that the ECC and ZF agree to.
Specifically, this ZIP contains no new conditions or procedural formalities on the delivery of development funds. This applies to technical and legal conditions and formalities.
There is only one expectation for these recipients. We recommend that they continue these items that they showed before this ZIP:
- Their stated missions.
- Their practices of transparency.
- Their responsiveness to community input.
Discussion
The primary differences between this ZIP and similar proposals are these two:
- This ZIP has no new conditions or processes for the disbursement of ZEC development funds.
- This ZIP has a fixed 50-50 division of funds between the ECC and ZF.
The reason for these differences is a desire for simplicity and continuity. This allocation can be implemented technically without new items of these types:
- Institutions.
- Processes.
- Legal agreements.
The adequate performance of fund recipients is expected for the reasons that follow. The expectation does not depend on lists of conditions with underspecified mechanisms for enforcement or dispute resolution.
- Aligned incentives. Specifically, the value of all funds that the recipients get over 4 years depends completely on the continued health and growth of the Zcash ecosystem.
- Proven records of the recipient entities and personnel. These are records of dedication to the Zcash project, and of effective work on related projects. The entities and personnel have these records even with no formal funding conditions.
Approximately 15% of the development funds of the original "Founders’ Reward" period was directed to the ZF. (That is, approximately 3 points of the full 20 points of bootstrap funds.)
But the ZF started later. Recently, the ZF increased its capabilities in these areas:
- Technical capabilities.
- Grantmaking capabilities.
- Organizational capabilities.
Also, there is a wide sentiment in the Zcash community, the ECC and the ZF about the role of the ZF. This sentiment is a wish that the ZF grows to a role of equal or greater importance than the ECC for long-term Zcash evolution. Thus this ZIP has a 50:50 split of future development funds. This split is in the place of a continuation of any previous proportions.
References
- [BCP14]
- Information on BCP 14 — "RFC 2119: Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement Levels" and "RFC 8174: Ambiguity of Uppercase vs Lowercase in RFC 2119 Key Words"