Zcash in Simplified Technical English

This page is the Simplified Technical English version of ZIP 1009. The source ZIP is the normative text. Read the writing rules to understand the marked words.

ZIP 1009: Five-Entity Strategic Council

ZIP: 1009
Title: Five-Entity Strategic Council
Owners: Avichal Garg <avichalgarg@electriccapital.com>
Status: Obsolete
Category: Consensus Process
Created: 2019-08-28
License: MIT
Discussions-To: <https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/dev-fund-proposal-5-entity-strategic-council-approach/34801>

Terminology

Key terms

Developer Fund
20% of the mined ZEC in the four-year period from approximately October 2020 to October 2024. In this period, a maximum of 5,250,000 ZEC will be minted.
Strategic Council
A five-person committee that determines how to allocate the Developer Fund. The Strategic Council is held accountable to the community through regular elections.
Executor
An individual or an organization (for example, a group or a company) that receives funding from the Strategic Council. Executors are responsible for excellent execution. The Strategic Council holds Executors accountable.

Abstract

In this ZIP, 20% of the newly minted coins in each block are reserved for a Developer Fund. The community elects a five-person Strategic Council every two years.

Every six months, the Strategic Council determines these items for the ecosystem:

The Strategic Council is responsible for two tasks. It allocates funding to Executors for the next six months. It also summarizes the performance of Executors in the previous six months.

Every six months, Executors send proposals to the Strategic Council. The proposals include these items:

At the end of six months, Executors grade themselves. Then the Strategic Council summarizes what was accomplished. The target is 7/10 in every quarter on a roll-up basis. (The roll-up is a simple average of all of the outstanding projects for that six months.)

Out of Scope for this Proposal

These items are out of scope for this ZIP:

Motivation and Requirements

In this ZIP, I try to put on my startup CEO hat. I address the strategic challenges and the execution challenges that, I believe, prevented Zcash from reaching its full potential.

Principles & Observations Based on My Experiences (a.k.a. Biases?)

Layer 1 protocols are driven by network effects. Thus, a layer 1 protocol ultimately collapses if it does not have a quickly growing network effect in these groups:

In a network-effect business, the primary cause of success is how quickly you grow the network effects.

To grow a network effect, you must have both the correct strategy and excellent execution. If your strategy is not correct, you will fail. The quality of your execution does not change this result. If your execution is not excellent, you will not be able to know the cause of a lack of progress. The cause can be poor execution or poor strategy.

Thus, to build the network effects that are necessary for the success of Zcash, we must answer five questions:

  1. Who determines the strategy?
  2. How do they decide on the strategy?
  3. How are they held accountable to having the correct strategy?
  4. Who executes?
  5. How are Executors held accountable to excellent execution?

1. Who determines the strategy?

2. How do they decide on the strategy?

3. How are they held accountable to having the correct strategy?

4. Who executes?

5. How are Executors held accountable to excellent execution?

Specification

1. Who determines strategy?

2. How do they decide?

How are they held accountable for having the correct strategy?

4. Who executes?

5. How are they held accountable to excellent execution?

Issues & Further Discussion

Raised objections, issues, and open questions:

References / Background

Editor note: we recommend that these items become inline references.

Change Log