This page is the Simplified Technical English version of ZIP 1005. The source ZIP is the normative text. Read the writing rules to understand the marked words.
ZIP 1005: Zcash Community Funding System
ZIP: 1005 Title: Zcash Community Funding System Owners: Dimitris Apostolou <dimitris.apostolou@icloud.com> Status: Obsolete Category: Consensus Process Created: 2019-06-23 License: MIT Discussions-To: <https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/zip-proposal-zcfs-zcash-community-funding-system/33898>
Abstract
This ZIP contains a proposal for a new funding mechanism, the Zcash Community Funding System (ZCFS).
Motivation
The motivations for the ZCFS are:
- The end of the Founders’ Reward is scheduled for 2020.
- The Founders’ Reward caused significant friction in the Zcash community. Disagreement with the existence of the Founders’ Reward itself was the cause of forks.
- A more fair and decentralized funding mechanism is necessary.
Specification
This specification is a modification of the Monero Community Crowdfunding System (CCS). The specification is as follows:
- The Founders’ Reward ends in October 2020. This end date is in the current consensus rules.
- The ‘proposer’ is an individual, team or company (for-profit or non-profit) that has an idea to improve the Zcash ecosystem. Funds are necessary for this idea.
- The proposer creates a ZCFS proposal in a modified version of the existing ZF Grants website. The name of this modified version will be the ZCFS website. The ZF Grants website already has the basic infrastructure for this mechanism. Small changes to it are necessary for this specification. The ZF Grants website will stay in operation in its current form.
- At the activation of this ZIP, the Zcash Foundation becomes responsible for the ZCFS.
- The Zcash Foundation must make ZCFS proposals for its own funding. If the community decides not to fund it, the ownership of the ZCFS is transferred to the proposer. The community funds this proposer instead for that matter.
Editor note: The meaning of "the proposer" here is unclear.
- After the creation of a ZCFS proposal, the community discusses the advantages and disadvantages of the proposal. The community also gives feedback and critique.
- The proposer changes the proposal (if necessary). The proposer uses the feedback and critique of the community for these changes.
- Repeat steps 6 and 7 as necessary.
- The Zcash Foundation (or the owner of the ZCFS at that time) determines that the community has loose consensus. After that, ZEC holders who want to donate start the funding.
- When the proposal is fully funded (this is not certain), the proposer starts the work, if the work is not already in progress.
- Milestones are completed. When a milestone is complete, funds are disbursed.
- After all milestones are complete, the proposal is locked. All information is kept for the future.
Rules and Expectations
The ZCFS is intentionally as informal as possible. Thus the system is flexible and is free from too much red tape. But there are some things that we recommend that you understand. Some things will be expected of you, as a proposer or as a donor. A recommended structure for a proposal also exists. With this structure, the probability that your project gets funds is at its maximum.
For Donors
- The Zcash Foundation (or the owner of the ZCFS at that time) holds the ZCFS in escrow. When you make a donation, you release funds to them. They disburse the funds when they think that the community agrees that a milestone is complete. They do not do the work to verify donors. The final decision for all disputes is theirs. But they do their best to follow the opinion of the community.
- A proposal can be overfunded or impossible to complete. Or a proposal can be in a different state where the donated money will not be disbursed to the proposer. In these events, the default is that the remaining ZEC will be put in the ZF Grants fund.
- Refunds are extremely rare. Donate with this knowledge.
- If the proposer disappears, this is not a problem. Someone else can continue from the last milestone of the proposer.
- The structure of milestones and payouts is different for each proposal. It depends on the wishes of the proposer. It is the responsibility of the donor to do due diligence about if they support the proposal in its entirety.
For Proposers
- It is not certain that your project will get past the community feedback stage. If it does, it is not certain that it will get funds.
- It is your responsibility to get support for your proposal during the feedback and funding stages. Do not expect others (especially the Zcash Foundation or other trusted members of the community) to do it for you. Others can share and support your proposal if they are excited about your project. But, at the end, this is only your responsibility.
- You are expected to give updates on the progress of your proposal to the community. For each completed milestone, we recommend that you put a written report into your ZCFS proposal. The report is an announcement of the completion of the milestone and of the work done. But, depending on the timeline of your project, it can be wise to update the community more often.
- All work must be licensed permissively at all stages of the proposal. Your work cannot have a restrictive license at any time (even while you work on it). If this problem is not corrected, your proposal will be terminated.
- In all circumstances, you must not include a donation address directly in your proposal. A donation address in the proposal is a way around the ZCFS. It can also be a cause of scams.
- You can start your work on the project before the proposal is fully funded. But funds are disbursed only on the completion of milestones, and only if the proposal is fully funded.