This page is the Simplified Technical English version of ZIP 1002. The source ZIP is the normative text. Read the writing rules to understand the marked words.
ZIP 1002: Opt-in Donation Feature
ZIP: 1002 Title: Opt-in Donation Feature Owners: mistfpga (zcash forums) <steve@mistfpga.net> Status: Obsolete Category: Consensus Process Created: 2019-07-17 License: CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> Discussions-To: <https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/zip-proposal-a-genuine-opt-in-protocol-level-development-donation-option/33846>
Terminology
On this page, STE words are in the place of the BCP 14 key words of the source. Refer to the key word table.
This ZIP contains these definitions of terms:
- Signalling
-
Signalling is the expression of a voice through the mechanism that is implemented or requested for that decision. In this ZIP, signalling is mainly about what to do with funds. Examples of the sources of a signal can be:
- miners
- a straw poll
- the coinbase
- proof of value
- an internet poll
- other mechanisms.
- Mining software
-
In this ZIP, mining software is one of these:
- pool software
- local mining software
- staking software.
- Custodial services
- A custodial service is any service where one party controls the private keys of a different party. Mining pools and online wallets are examples.
- Mining
- Mining is the processing of transactions. Thus mining includes proof of stake, if Zcash changes to proof of stake.
- User
- A user is any person who uses ZEC, or a different coin where this ZIP is adopted.
- Rewards and distribution
- Mining coins that are transferred through fees are rewards (infinite). Coins that are generated through block generation are distribution (finite).
- Opt-in and opt-out
- In the context of this ZIP, to opt out is a purely selfish act. The persons who opt out do not burn the coins, and thus do not give value to all persons. They keep the coins.
- Burning coins
- To burn coins is to take them out of circulation forever, on purpose, at the level of protocol block distribution.
- Initial promise
- The initial promise is the complete honour of the distribution of all rewards to the miner. This phrase is not neutral. The author accepts that.
- Transaction sender
-
A transaction sender is any person who sends a transaction across the Zcash network. The transaction can be one of these types:
- t-t
- z-z
- t-z
- z-t.
- Fee
- The fee is the conventional transaction fee that a sender puts on a transaction. The sender puts the fee on the transaction to get the transaction into a block. The miner of that block collects the fee.
- Transaction donation
- A transaction donation is an optional signalling string. With this string, a payment to the coinbase donations is created.
- Block Reward
- The block reward is the block distribution plus the mining fees.
- Spirit
- The spirit is the intended outcome of this ZIP. [spirit]
[spirit] A contradiction between the spirit and a different part of this ZIP can occur, and it can be necessary to solve it. If that contradiction is not solved, the spirit is assumed to have priority over all.
Out of Scope for this Proposal
Governance, that is, how decisions are made, is out of scope. This ZIP is not for use as a form of governance. It is a protocol-level opt-in to support the development of the Zcash network (like the Founders’ Reward, but with opt-out).
Signalling is out of scope. Much of this ZIP depends on the ability to signal intent in some way. But this ZIP does not contain a signalling mechanism. This ZIP is designed for use with different forms of signalling, or possibly with no signalling.
Abstract
The spirit of this ZIP is:
-
To let a user give continual funding to one of these, if the user selects to do so:
- the Electric Coin Company
- the Zcash Foundation
- a combination of these.
- To add a genuine opt-in feature. The user makes the choice to use this feature.
Motivation
Technology changes, and it changes quickly. In 10 years or 20 years, it can be easy to break what works now. In 50 years, this is certainly true.
To help make sure that ZEC can stay current with these changes, now and in 50 or 500 years, continual funding is necessary. This funding is for research into new technology, and for the financial stability that is necessary to attract new talent.
The only source of indefinite wealth transfer is transaction fees or donations. This ZIP is specifically about voluntary donations (including donations through mining fees).
Requirements
- An additional opt-in mechanism that is built into the protocol. This is also a condition of the Zcash Foundation. [foundation]
- Give an alternative to a redistribution of the current block distribution structure or of the emission curve.
- The recipients of the funding under this ZIP are the Electric Coin Company, the Zcash Foundation, or both. The funding that they get under this ZIP must only be used to fund ZEC development for all the time that they get it.
- Give a strong indication to the community and to users that they are free to decide what they do with their coins and donations.
- Build the addresses into the node codebase, so that wallet implementations or pool software do not have to keep a record of donation addresses.
- Prevent users from sending donations to old addresses.
- Make it easier for pools to add support. Make it easier for pools to prove that they really donate the percentage that they say.
- Users must not be forced to signal.
[foundation] The Zcash Foundation stated that it supports only the proposals that agree with these conditions. (Later, the Foundation made this statement clearer in [zfnd-guidance].)
- The proposal does not depend on the Foundation as a single gatekeeper of funds.
- The proposal does not change the upper limit of the ZEC supply.
- The proposal has an opt-in mechanism of some type for the choice to pay out funds (from miners, users, or both).
Specification
- By default, the initial promise, as defined above, must be enforced by this ZIP.
- By default, the official implementation must be counted as initial promise.
- When a pool is used, the absence of a signal must be counted as the signal of the pool.
- Security must not be decreased.
- This ZIP can be set to opt-in through a flag that the user sets.
- This ZIP must contain donation addresses in the coinbase, similar to the current FR.
- When the sender sends transactions, the sender can signal the donation.
- The default signal of the transaction processor for a transaction must not be overridden by a signal from the transaction sender.
- A transaction sender can select to include separate donation fees. The transaction processor must not override these donation fees, if this is used or not.
Editor's note: This ZIP is published as a ZIP for discussion, and for the sentiment collection process of the Zcash Foundation. The ZIP is published although the specification above has significant problems with lack of clarity.
Raised objections and issues so far
- With this ZIP, the protocol is more complex. This complexity is not technically necessary, and it is usually a bad idea.
- With this ZIP, there is nothing new that users cannot already do manually under the current protocol. But users cannot do it to the same extent.
- Block sizes: this ZIP can have an effect on the motivation to increase block sizes, if that becomes necessary.
- What happens with signalling from shielded addresses to donations at taddresses?
- When Zcash changes to z addresses only, how will the transparency of donations be proven?
- ZEC is designed to have no high transaction fees and no secondary market for transaction fees. Is this a core principle?
- A similar goal is possible without the initial promise, with only a burn. mistfpga: I do not like to take coins out of circulation intentionally. It is an attempt to avoid that.
- Further note: If burn must be an option, I want to use an option similar to the "rolling burn" option. Editor's note: The "rolling burn" option is not defined. The intention was to write a different ZIP to define it, but that ZIP was not written.
Implications to other users
- It will be necessary to consider wallet development. We hope that the requirements will decrease this effect after the first change.
-
If the Electric Coin Company, the Zcash Foundation, or both close down, what will be the result for the donations? The possible answers are:
- The donations go into the mining fee.
- The donations are burnt.
- The donations are sent as change to the original sender.
- The donations are distributed through some other mechanism.
Technical implementation
These items are already implemented in some form:
- Some wallets already implement optional fees.
- Miners already cannot override optional fees.
- Hardcoded donation addresses are already built into the protocol. Thus the work to change them to the signalling addresses is probably small.
- Pools and implementations already cannot change the hardcoded donation address.
- Signalling can be handled at the pool level.
- Pools already add their own addresses to the coinbase, including donations.
References
- [BCP14]
- Information on BCP 14 — "RFC 2119: Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement Levels" and "RFC 8174: Ambiguity of Uppercase vs Lowercase in RFC 2119 Key Words"
- [zfnd-guidance]
- Zcash Foundation Guidance on Dev Fund Proposals. Zcash Foundation blog, August 6, 2019.